We had two claims - one adjuster never returned my calls, but the other adjuster Charles was very helpful and was always giving me info. I had to call Faron's supervisor and talk to her and then I called him the next day and he answered.
William from NC
| August 04, 2025
Treated Professionally
Yes
Prompt Service
Yes
Would Recommend
Yes
Overall Rate
★★★★★
Service was better than I could have hoped for.
Richard and Elaine from OR
| August 01, 2025
Treated Professionally
Yes
Prompt Service
Yes
Would Recommend
Yes
Overall Rate
★★★★☆
The amount paid on the claim was too low, about 65% of what I though was reasonable.
Suzanne from AZ
| July 31, 2025
Treated Professionally
Yes
Prompt Service
No
Overall Rate
★★★★☆
1) One check was made out just to me to pay forward to restoration company, next check for remediation company was made out to me and another party - which was not the correct party as lienholder. Not sure why this difference. It slowed the process d...
show more
1) One check was made out just to me to pay forward to restoration company, next check for remediation company was made out to me and another party - which was not the correct party as lienholder. Not sure why this difference. It slowed the process down. 2) Both companies invoices were higher than what Stillwater paid them. I was told the amounts had been negotiated but both companies invoices were higher and they didn't seem to know about the reduction in price and contacted me for help. I took myself out of the middle and referred them back to Stillwater agent. show less
Ashley from NJ
| July 28, 2025
Treated Professionally
Yes
Prompt Service
Yes
Would Recommend
Yes
Overall Rate
★★★★★
I am very impressed with Adam's handling of my claim! In fact, I have recommended my brother to switch over to Stillwater. Thank you!
Robert from CA
| July 25, 2025
Treated Professionally
Yes
Prompt Service
No
Would Recommend
No
Overall Rate
★★★☆☆
Difficult to communicate. Phone calls not returned. Left me hanging.
Sarah from AZ
| July 23, 2025
Treated Professionally
Yes
Prompt Service
Yes
Would Recommend
Yes
Overall Rate
★★★★★
He was professional, friendly and timely with responses.
Sol from NY
| July 23, 2025
Treated Professionally
Yes
Prompt Service
Yes
Would Recommend
Yes
Overall Rate
★★★★★
It's the best car insurance. Love it. I would recommend it to friends and family. Thanks so much.