When it comes to protecting your assets, we make the grade.

Better Business Bureau "A+" Rated Business

Stillwater's "A+" accreditation with the Better Business Bureau signifies that our customers always come first. We set ourselves apart from other companies by walking the walk when it comes to responding to customer's needs, and we deliver on our promises with transparency and integrity. Our focus will always be to take care of our customers when they need us most.

Better Business Bureau

AM Best "A-" Rated Financial Strength: Excellent

Not only does Stillwater stand tall - we stand firm. Our "A-" (Excellent) rating from AM Best, a credit rating agency focused on the insurance industry, demonstrates we have the financial strength and capability to guarantee our customers' polices and keep them secure. This gives our customers peace of mind knowing they can trust us to be there when life takes its unexpected turns. This rating is granted to Stillwater Insurance Company and Stillwater Property and Casualty Insurance Company.

AM Best Financial Strength

Demotech "A" Rated Financial Stability: Exceptional

Our "A" (Exceptional) rating from Demotech Inc., with its proven track record of predicting financial stability in the insurance industry, substantiates that we are just as financially stable as the largest insurance providers. Our customers can be assured that we will always be able to take care of them, regardless of changes in the economy or marketplace. This rating is granted to Stillwater Insurance Company and Stillwater Property and Casualty Insurance Company.

BBB Torch Award for Ethics (2017)

This award recognizes trustworthy organizations that demonstrate best practices, leadership, social responsibility and high standards of organizational ethics that benefit their customers, employees, vendors and local communities. Being awarded this honor supports our mission of always doing the right thing, even when nobody is looking.

Torch awards

Jacksonville Business Journal "Best Place to Work" Winner (2019)

This award recognizes companies that go above and beyond the norm to foster an enjoyable and meaningful work environment for their employees. Out of hundreds of nominated North Florida businesses, we were #7 in the top 10 large companies (100-249 employees) category. Based off anonymous responses gathered from company employees via an online survey, the words most often used to describe the working environment at Stillwater include "friendly", "challenging", "professional", "family", "teamwork" and "caring".

Best Place to Work Award